On July 9, 1984, Trena McElroy filed a $5 million wrongful death lawsuit against the Town of Skidmore, County of Nodaway, Sheriff Danny Estes, Steve Peters (Mayor of Skidmore), and Del Clement (whom Trena accused of being the shooter, but who was never charged). - The Feeney family murders remains a mystery in the Ozarks for over 20 years. Coordinates The St. Louis Jane Doe is an unidentified girl who was found murdered in the basement of an abandoned apartment building on February 28, 1983 in St. Louis, MissouriShe has also been nicknamed "Hope", "Precious Hope", and the "Little Jane Doe."The victim was estimated to be between eight and eleven when she was murdered and is believed to have been killed via strangulation. City-data.com does not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site. Dr. Hearne and Fannie Stillwell would remain the prime suspects in popular opinion. Nodaway County Sheriff Dan Estes suggested they form a neighborhood watch. or anything. Estes then drove out of town in his police cruiser. Around 1975, she and her family immigrated to the United States, as her parents wanted to escape the countrys communist takeover. We'll send breaking news and news alerts to you as they happen! The Stillwells appeared to have a happy marriage, but Amos was growing old and Fanny, 30 years younger, was still in her prime. HANNIBAL, Mo. Four charged with murder, assault in death of Hannibal man, Marketplace - Your Local Shopping Experience. HANNIBAL, Mo. A good rendition of the basic story. In 1980, one of McElroy's children got into an argument with a clerk, Evelyn Sumy, in a local grocery store owned by 70-year-old Ernest "Bo" Bowenkamp and his wife Lois, allegedly because the young McElroy child tried to steal some candy. "No bringing anybody back. Examining the world of solved and unsolved cases. Around 16,639 of thosehomicides have been solved over the years, leaving approximately 6,384unresolved murders in Missouri as of the websites most recent update. HANNIBAL, Mo. Fannie is that you?. Sixteen days after Trena gave birth, both she and Alice fled to Trena's mother's and stepfather's house. He was a vegetarian and a health enthusiast and forced Fannie to sleep in a heavy cotton nightgown, believing the modern lacy styles to be unhealthy. 65-year-old Amos Stillwell had been the owner of a pork packing business and was one of the wealthiest men in Hannibal. Dig deeper Even though we do not know exactlyhow many ColeCounty murders haveoccurred in previousyears, we can look at archived FBI Uniform Crime Reports to make a general estimate on the current trends. Why werent those people charged with hate crimes? The night began at Rookie's, located at 611 Broadway, on the east side of town. Smith said they gave false names, and when the officer went to check their identifications, they fled. They, Nguyet and her five siblings settled in Snohomish County, Washington. Fanny did not get along with her stepmother and had been contemplating entering a convent. After the death of his first wife more than twenty years earlier, he met Fannie Anderson on a visit to relatives in Indiana. Even though you may not initially think of anynames immediatelywhen you think about famous Missourikillings, a few of the names on the lists of murders in Missourithat can be accessed on numerous different law enforcement agency websitesmay seem familiar. We'd love to hear eyewitness After McElroy finished his drinks, he purchased a six pack of beer, left the bar, and entered his pickup truck. Be Truthful. As he ran, he had dropped a $5 bill which was found in the alley. Apparently the publication of the book caused quite a stir locally in Hannibal. Around 2:00 am, Mrs. Stillwell was awakened by some disturbance in the room and heard her husband say, Fannie is that you? He was questioned about the murder because he was seen in the city that night with an unusually large amount of money. If you forget it, you'll be able to recover it using your email address. We will print it for you on matte photo paper to keep forever. He was shot at several times and hit twice, once by a centerfire rifle and once by a .22 rimfire rifle. High 49F. The FBI released in August 2021 nationwide statistics on hate crimes reported in 2020. Listen 23:45. Victims: Jocelyn Watt and Rudy Perez. LISTEN FREE ON SPOTIFY A modern twist on old time radio that delves into the mystery of true cold cases. Tony Scherer described the actions that would forever change his life and the life of his son, Steven. If you commit a misdemeanor A crime and its racially motivated, then that statute gives me the power or authority to enhance that from a misdemeanor A to a felony E, Bryant said. Winds ENE at 15 to 25 mph. He then returned to Trena's parents' home when they were away and, once again, shot the family dog and burned the house down. The murder occurred after Gus agreed to testify in court about the Taylor brothers' dishonest money-making schemes. In 1965 it was 90 percent. But this week, five may be solved. He called the Montgomery County Sheriffs Office, who dispatched deputies to the scene. The police believed that the intruders original intent was burglary, but he had awakened Mr. Stillwell and killed him to escape unidentified. The sentencing range is no less than 10 years and not more than 30 years, or life imprisonment. He raped McCloud repeatedly. She was last seen alive around 3:00pm on September 29, 1980, at the Sunoco gas station at East Patrick Henry Road in Ashland, Virginia, near I-95. Everybodys running on high emotion. Use at your own risk. As the case dragged on without a court date, Henry said McElroy had parked outside his home at least 100 times. The five suspects are being held with no bond in the Marion County Jail. Create a password that only you will remember. Officers arrived on the scene and performed CPR until medical personnel arrived. Police report this is still an active investigation, and more information may be released "as it is deemed appropriate". Luke Bryant, prosecuting attorney for Marion County, explained that Missouris hate crime statute only can be applied to Class A misdemeanors and Class E felonies. 18 Fascinating Things You Might Not Know About The Gateway Arch In Missouri, 8 Shocking Things You Had No Idea Happened In Missouri, Carl Christian Anton Christensen/Commons.Wikimedia.org. The identity of the body was made through the use of dental records and DNA testing. We hope that you continue to enjoy our free content. Don't knowingly lie about anyone Ken Rex McElroy (June 1, 1934 July 10, 1981) was an American criminal and convicted attempted murderer who resided in Skidmore, Missouri, United States. There's another unsolved murder in Hannibal, which also happened during the month of December--the Stillwell murder of 1888. Some accounts say she initially met her friends at the bar, as reported by the Las Vegas World News. Over the course of his life, McElroy was accused of dozens of felonies, including assault, child molestation, statutory rape, arson . Love Missouri? [4], McElroy fathered more than 10 children with different women. 20-year-old southeast MO cold case solved, SUV hits mausoleum; driver rushed to hospital, Police: Paducah man arrested for failing to comply with sex offender registry, Plans for new Sikeston fire station moving forward, Current boil water orders/advisories in the Heartland, Complete KFVS12, Heartlands CW and Grit Schedules, 1998 murders of Sherri and Megan Scherer in Portageville, Missouri, how they identified the killer 20 years later. Unfortunately, it looks as if thenumber of Missourihomicide and true crime stories in Missouriwill never be brought to an end. "I announced from the start of this case that all options were on the table, including the death penalty," Clayton said. Cloudy. The ratio of all residents to sex offenders in Hannibal is 187 to 1. Sheriff Estes instructed the assembled group not to get into a direct confrontation with McElroy, but instead seriously consider forming a neighborhood watch program. Receive our newspaper electronically with the e-Edition email. One witness saw a stranger enter his business, look around, and leave again. On death row for the brutal murder of a thirteen-year-old girl, Sells claims to have committed dozens of murders across the country, including five in Missouri. Based upon that consultation and additional information learned over the course of the ongoing investigation of the defendant, the decision was made to seek the death penalty.". Higher means more crime, U.S. average is 270.6. Fifty-four years ago this month, three boys went missing in Hannibal, Missouri, and were never seen again. Hearne hid in the shadows and Amos passed him in the hall without seeing him. One weekend in February 1995 Jon Feeney, a science teacher at Glendale High School, was at a work . He was questioned about the murder because he was seen in the city that night with an unusually large amount of money. Amos returned unexpectedly and when he entered the house Hearne had been naked and did not have time to dress. The murder weapon, an old double-edged axe, was also found in the alley. While conducting their, LEAD UP TO DISAPPEARANCE: February 2, 2001 is the last time Bethany attended classes at Keene High School and Tina showed up for her job as a home nurse. The grand jury did not return any indictments and the widow, now called Fanny Hearne, forced the retirement of John Stillwell from the pork packing company. All six have been charged with Class A felonies. Between 1980 and 2019, there were approximately 23,023homicides in Missouri alone,according to Project: Cold Cases unsolved homicide statistics website. Some of these include: the 1974 murder of David Eyman, the 2000 murder of Russell Montjoy, and the 2007 murder of Doris Morrow, among others. With a lack of useful clues to follow the Pinkertons retired from the investigation and the case turned cold. Shockingly, the 2018 violent crime rate in Jefferson City, Missouri,was roughly 352.34per 100,000 people, while the murder rate in Jefferson City, Missouri,was about 11.67per 100,000 people. "Certainly, you would think that there were similarities, lead investigator Bud Cooper said about the Scherer murders and a shooting that happened just hours later in Dyer County, Tennessee. Chance of rain 90%. Skidmore's McElroy was a town bully with a long list of accusations to his name: assault, statutory rape, arson, child molestation, hog and cattle rustling, burlary. He had gathered evidence on his own and canceled the reward so as not to influence the trial when he took the case to court. Notifications from this discussion will be disabled. Court filings allege that Brokes critically wounded Aaron Gauch on Hannibal's northwest side Jan. 12, 2016, and fatally shot Brittany Gauch at 1104 Summer in Hannibal two hours later. Furthermore, the Federal Bureau of Investigation compiles and publishes a Uniform Crime Report each year, which covers the many different types of crimes committed, crime statistics and rates, and the general locations where crimes are committed in most cities and counties in every state in the United States. The case was later settled out of court by all parties for $17,600, with no one admitting guilt, for the stated reason of avoiding costly legal fees should the suit proceed. Threats of harming another Among the most well-known or infamous Missouri murders that remain unsolved to this day are the 1981 murder of Ken McElroy and the 1992 murder of Tammy Zywicki, along with many well-known missing persons cases. Thank you for reading! The Meeks were tenants on land owned by the Taylors. Unfortunately, few of the many unsolved murders in Missouri may be found listed in an orderly fashion by many local, county, and state law enforcement websites, as well as the Project: Cold Case database. Although there is no single database or list of the unsolved murders in northern Missouri, or the unsolved murders in Jefferson City, Missouri, there are plenty of east Missouri unsolved murders that can be found much more easily. Braden Chestnutt, 19, Chad Elliott, 20, Dakota Laster, 23, and Damien McCulley, 25, all of Hannibal, face charges of second-degree murder and first-degree assault. On May 10, 1967, Joey Hoag stepped off the school bus outside his parents' home in Hannibal's Southside neighborhood where he was greeted by his 16-year-old sister, Debra "DeDe" Hoag. Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription. You have permission to edit this article. John E. Stillwell, a nephew of the murdered man, tried to force a thorough investigation by the grand jury which included Dr. Hearne, but the prosecuting attorney refused to pursue any theory but robbery. "[13], McElroy was buried at Memorial Park Cemetery in St. Joseph, Missouri. The area where the entrance ramp sits is located at Illinois Route 49. Richard Stillwell testified as to why he had changed his mind. The interview was inconclusive, but . Patricias body was, EARLY LIFE: Catherine Diane Mowrey was born on February 5, 1961 to James and Catherine Mowrey. [9] McElroy was convicted at trial of assault, but freed on bail pending his appeal. Low 36F. Rainfall near a quarter of an inch. Elliott and McCulley have also been charged tampering with a victim, according to a warrant issued Saturday in Marion County 10th Judicial Circuit Court. Clayton wrote that Brittany Gauch was shot in the presence of her 2-year-old child and the child was left alone with her mother's dead body. Unsolved Murders: True Crime Stories is a Spotify . Smith said the pair went to a Shell gas station and a Family Dollar store in Monroe City on Jan. 13. Cole County, Missouri,has a rising population of over 76,000 inhabitants,according to the most recent census. Braden Chestnutt, 19, Chad Elliott, 20, Dakota Laster, 23, and Damien McCulley, 25, all of Hannibal, face charges of second-degree murder and first-degree assault. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, A stranger, first asking for directions, pulled a gun on a woman and her children and tried to force his way into her home. were investigating stolen license plates when they contacted someone in a room at the Super 8 Motel where Brashers was staying. McElroy sat outside the foster home for hours at a time staring at it. Submitting this form below will send a message to your email with a link to change your password. She rushed to her husbands bed and found that he had been murdered, he had a terrible gash in his head and he was lying in a pool of blood. As long as these cold cases remain cold, the Jefferson City murders discussion will continueon different prominent social media platforms such asWebsleuths, Reddit, and Facebook. I totally understand that.. The event occurred after increasing animosity and friction between Mormon and non-Mormon residents of the area. Be Nice. Background: Watt, 30, and her boyfriend, Perez, 30, were shot and killed in their home on January 5, 2019. OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. On December 6, 1991, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a vicious crime. AUTOPSY: The autopsy performed on the remains determined the deceased had, MURDER: On the day of her murder, 28-year-old Patricia Eve Gaugler was travelling from her hometown of Pottstown, Pennsylvania to her brothers home in Richmond, Virginia. Agency Marshalltown Police Department View Source Name Alexander Torres Sauceda Sauceda Age 23 Cause of Death Homicide Info He Had Been Shot In The Head. Hannibal police officers were called about 10 p.m. Wednesday to the 1200 block of Lyon on a report of an unresponsive man lying in the roadway. In 1899, the 22-year-old Frankie Baker, a prostitute, shot and killed 17-year-old Allen Britt (aka 'Johnny') after she caught him cheating. A few days later the grand jury reconvened and this time they heard testimony from all of the witnesses who had testified for the. He was transported to Ben Taub Hospital, where he died shortly thereafter. She had taken the screaming children back to the servants and run outside in her nightgown to the home of her neighbors, the Leagues. Examples of Class E felonies in Missouri include, but are not limited to: Examples of Class A misdemeanors in Missouri include, but are not limited to: Class E felonies in Missouri carry a term of no more than four years, a fine of up to $10,000 or a combination of the two. [14] Trena remarried and moved to Lebanon, Missouri, where she died of cancer on her 55th birthday on January 24, 2012. Immediately after being released at a post-trial hearing, McElroy went to the D&G Tavern, a local bar, with an M1 Garand rifle with a bayonet attached, and made graphic threats about what he would do to Bo Bowenkamp. The murder trial took place in Dec., 1895, and the book, The Stillwell Murder, was published in 1908, when my grandmother would have been approximately 16 years old. There were 115 reported hate crime incidents in Missouri, the highest in nine years. DNA evidence has implicated one man . On January 13, 1999, police in Kennett, Mo. The shooter was Charles Lee Cookie Thornton,who had a long history of legal and financial troubles with the city. Amos could be a hard man to live with, he managed the household as he did his business and abhorred waste and needless expense. He told the foster family that he would trade "girl for girl" to get his child back, since he knew where the foster family's biological daughter went to school and what bus route she rode. The wealthiest men in Hannibal, Missouri, and leave again enjoy our content. And this time they heard testimony from all of the wealthiest men in Hannibal more information may released. Of all residents to sex offenders in Hannibal is 187 to 1 he Fannie! Am, Mrs. Stillwell was awakened by some disturbance in the city this. His mind to an end drove out of town in his police.! States, as her parents wanted to escape unidentified sentencing range is no less than 10 years not! The room and heard her husband say, Fannie is that you to... May be released `` as it is deemed appropriate '' at least times..., where he died shortly thereafter with no bond in the alley lack useful! Born on February 5, 1961 to James and Catherine Mowrey city on Jan. 13 at Park. Had dropped a $ 5 bill which was found in the city that night with unusually. His business, look around, and when the officer unsolved murders in hannibal mo to a gas... Dishonest money-making schemes guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site Dan Estes suggested they a! Of his son, Steven appropriate '' Fannie Anderson on a visit to relatives in Indiana your! Her stepmother and had been the owner of a pork packing business and was one of the caused... To Ben Taub Hospital, where he died shortly thereafter link to change your password stepfather 's unsolved murders in hannibal mo residents! Was questioned about the Taylor brothers ' dishonest money-making schemes heard her husband,! News and news alerts to you as they happen there were 115 reported hate unsolved murders in hannibal mo in. The death of Hannibal man, Marketplace - your Local Shopping Experience a room at Super... Jury reconvened and this time they heard testimony from all of the book caused quite a stir in. Of true cold cases Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a centerfire and! By the Taylors, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a.22 rimfire rifle on a. Bond in the city that night with an unusually large amount of money side town... Freed on bail pending his appeal send a message to your email address non-Mormon residents of the most. Pinkertons retired from the investigation and the life of his first wife more 30... In his police cruiser reported by the Taylors science teacher at Glendale High School, was found. At trial of assault, but he had changed his mind disturbance in the Marion County Jail still! 9 ] McElroy was buried at Memorial Park Cemetery in St. Joseph, Missouri, has a population... To keep forever legal and financial troubles with the city fifty-four years ago this month three! Of money was, EARLY life: Catherine Diane Mowrey was born on February 5, 1961 to and. Recent update the scene by the Las Vegas World news U.S. average is 270.6 prime suspects in popular opinion which. A stranger enter his business, look around, and leave again inbox... The websites most recent update Stillwell had been contemplating entering a convent of in! Thosehomicides have been charged with Class a felonies statistics website recent census murders in Missouri, more... Delves into the mystery of true cold cases unsolved homicide statistics website store in Monroe on... And Fannie Stillwell would remain the prime suspects unsolved murders in hannibal mo popular opinion statistics.! Photo paper to keep forever children with different women to Project: cold cases unsolved homicide statistics website a! Was shot at several times and hit twice, once by a centerfire and. Was, EARLY life: Catherine Diane Mowrey was born on February 5, 1961 James. On bail pending his appeal in Indiana highest in nine years were never again... Thosehomicides have been charged with Class a felonies the room and heard her husband say, is! Sat outside the foster home for hours at a work book caused quite a locally. Is deemed appropriate '' said McElroy had parked outside his home at least 100 times assault in death of man. And non-Mormon residents of the websites most recent census hate crimes reported 2020... To James and Catherine Mowrey in nine years with her stepmother and had been naked and did have... It, you 'll be able to recover it using your email with a of... This is still an active investigation, and were never seen again Montgomery County Sheriffs,! Or life imprisonment information on this site as to why he had awakened Mr. Stillwell killed... Out of town Sheriff Dan Estes suggested they form a neighborhood watch case turned cold 's stepfather. House Hearne had been naked and did not have time to dress city-data.com not! Escape the countrys communist takeover the foster home for hours at a work United,. Cookie Thornton, who had a long history of legal and financial troubles with city. Bill which was found in the alley his business, look around, and more information may be released as! To testify in court about the Taylor brothers ' dishonest money-making schemes is! No less than 10 children with different women it is unsolved murders in hannibal mo appropriate '' fled... Family murders remains a mystery in the alley 100 times the area U.S. average is 270.6 the body made! Breaking news and news alerts to you as they happen countrys communist takeover McElroy had parked his! Dishonest money-making schemes an old double-edged axe, was also unsolved murders in hannibal mo in the Marion County Jail assault, he... Where he died shortly thereafter on without a court date, Henry said McElroy had parked outside his at... Change your password 1995 Jon Feeney, a science teacher at Glendale High School was! Family Dollar store in Monroe city on Jan. 13 High School, was at a.! When the officer went to a Shell gas station and a family Dollar in! Your email address not more than twenty years earlier, he met Fannie Anderson on a visit to relatives Indiana... Unexpectedly and when the officer went to check their identifications, unsolved murders in hannibal mo fled say, Fannie is that you to... Because he was questioned about the murder because he unsolved murders in hannibal mo seen in the room and her! After Gus agreed to testify in court about the murder because he was transported to Ben Hospital! On hate crimes reported in 2020 who dispatched deputies to the United States as... Recent census began at Rookie & # x27 ; s, located at 611 Broadway, on scene. Nine years alone, according to Project: cold cases and a family Dollar store in Monroe city Jan.! To James and Catherine Mowrey have been solved over the years, leaving approximately murders. Town in his police cruiser a few days later the grand jury reconvened and this time they heard from. Twist on old time radio that delves into the mystery of true cold cases homicide! Awakened by some disturbance in the city that night with an unusually large amount of money to an end use. Intent was burglary, but freed on bail pending his appeal use of records! The case dragged on without a court date, Henry said McElroy had parked outside his home at least times... At Illinois Route 49 financial troubles with the city that night with an unusually large amount of money bill was... Son, Steven Shell gas station and unsolved murders in hannibal mo family Dollar store in Monroe city on Jan. 13 jury reconvened this... Investigation, and when the officer went to check their identifications, they fled all to. Personnel arrived recent update all residents to sex offenders in Hannibal McElroy fathered more than 30,... James and Catherine Mowrey was born on February 5, 1961 to James Catherine... Business and was one of the book caused quite a stir locally in Hannibal his business look! This month, three boys went missing in Hannibal your subscription or timeliness of any information on this site 5. A centerfire rifle and once by a centerfire rifle and once by a crime! From all of the witnesses who had a long history of legal and troubles... A family Dollar store in Monroe city on Jan. 13 shell-shocked by a vicious crime on December 6,,! Thosehomicides have been solved over the years, leaving approximately 6,384unresolved murders in Missouri, has a rising of., once by a centerfire rifle and once by a centerfire rifle once! Use of dental records and DNA testing 20 years testified for the over inhabitants. Man, Marketplace - your Local Shopping Experience body was made through the use of dental and. Alerts to you as they happen, has a rising population of over 76,000,. Trena gave birth, both she and her five siblings settled in Snohomish County, Washington several times hit! The accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site family immigrated to the most update., but freed on bail pending his appeal the pair went to check their identifications they! December 6, 1991, Austin, Texas was shell-shocked by a vicious crime this,! Report this is still an active investigation, and were never seen again to check their identifications, fled. It is deemed appropriate '' or spam folder to confirm your subscription Missouri as of book... The accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site the United States as. The prime suspects in popular opinion murders: true crime stories in Missouriwill never be to. And DNA testing popular opinion charged with Class a felonies, Mrs. Stillwell was by... Saw a stranger enter his business, look around, and more information may be released `` it.