Sometimes he wont have been thinking about the situation at all. My sister basically spent her life searching for something that would make her happy, says Kara. One of Tims favorite places, Brookfield Zoo, was not far away, and a mechanic dropped the mother and son off there. Timmothy and I will be fine. Later that day, Jim grew panicky. The vehicles are projects hes taken on over the years to take his mind off the gnawing anguish. When James returned to the school to pick Timmothy up he was told Amy withdrew him from class hours earlier. They also found a partially consumed bottle of Triaminic, a liquid cough and cold medicine for children, and Tims child identification card. I went home and found a dot matrix photo of them at a Chuck E. Cheese and said, This is the best I can do off the top of my head. They said, OK, well file this, and if something else happens, well get back to you., Friday afternoon, Amy finally reached out. The . In the country that is now known as the United States of America, there have been a number of instances of people going missing; one of these is the case of Timothy Pitzen. Especially after the dissolution of her first marriage, Pitzen was confident that he could be of assistance to her by cultivating a positive . Tuesday marked Timmothy Pitzen's 18th birthday, and after 11 years, his family still holds out hope that he's alive. He soon got a call from a hospital in Cedar Rapids. Included in Amys note: a message to the motel staff that she was sorry they would have to clean up after her. Fry-Pitzen, who was suffering from depression and going through an unhappy marriage at the time, was found dead from suicide May 14, 2011, inside a motel room in Rockford, Illinois, according to . The arguments could be over anything. The detectives explained that she had been found in a Rockford motel, dead of an apparent suicide. Timmothy Pitzen: New Forensic Image Released 10 Years After Boy's Disappearance Timmothy's case has been a mystery since 2011, when police found the boy's mother dead of an apparent suicide along . The complaint was filed against their son as well. Soon they were seeing each other regularly. He didnt speak much. Despite this, Timmothy remained missing. It was a family emergency, Amy Fry-Pitzen told his teachers. That she did on this occasion must have meant she was hurting badly. [4] Cell phone records indicated the calls were made from an area northwest of Sterling, Illinois, near Route 40. Jim & Amy Pitzen Met at a Party, & Were Married in 2004 According to CNN, Amy and Jim met at a party and dated long distance before marrying. Pauline M. Pitzen, age 74, of Lancaster, WI passed away on Wednesday, September 29, 2021, at Grant Regional Health Center in Lancaster. But Amys I-Pass history showed that months earlier she made two trips to the Sterling area, which she never mentioned to Jim or any other family member. They recently celebrated 62 years of . A security camera showed Amy entering a food market near Rockford on May 13, but there is no sign of Timmothy with her. Shed been married once before, per the network, and Jim said he thought her depression would improve once she was in a healthy relationship. I had a go-kart in the back shed, and when Tim was about 3, I made the gas pedal so you couldnt push it all the way down. What was unusual this time was that she took Tim with her. Timmothy belongs to me. He tried to get in touch with her numerous times, but she did not pick up any of his calls or respond to any of his messages. Jim walked me past that chaotic room with an utter lack of self-consciousness that seemed in keeping with a man of few words, not easily given to outward emotion. But that, like so many other promising things, was followed by an inevitable letdown. "[16], The man who claimed to be Pitzen was found to be 23-year-old Brian Michael Rini. Search Spans Three States for Boy From Aurora, the Chicago Tribune announced. She was born May 3, 1968 to Lee and Alana (Anderson) Fry. That wouldn't be true until the following day, when Pitzen's father reported the pair missing. She was born May 3, 1968 to Lee and Alana (Anderson) Fry. But this is the face that we ask everybody to look at closely, because we know that its one way he can be found.. He went back to work but couldnt concentrate. Amy Pitzen's Suicide And The Disturbing Surveillance Footage That Surfaced Afterward On Saturday, May 14, staff at a Rockford, Illinois motel 80 miles away from Timmothy's home found Amy's lifeless body. Three months in, the police confirmed that the blood they had found in the back seat of Amys SUV was Tims. Heres what you need to know about Timmothy Pitzens father: According to CNN, Amy and Jim met at a party and dated long distance before marrying. As authorities continue to search for the child, details about Fry-Pitzen's troubled past began to emerge. Timmothy belongs to me. They returned and retrieved their vehicle at 3:00 PM, and drove to the KeyLime Cove Resort in Gurnee, where they spent the night. Jim had tried to stay in that Aurora home. I miss you. No response. ', Timmothy vanished in 2011, after his mom, Amy Fry-Pitzen, committed suicide in a motel room and left a note saying the boy was safe but would never be found. The following Friday, the wake for Amy was held at her place of worship: the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Sugar Grove, Illinois. He claimed that he had. The case of Timmothy Pitzen, who vanished in 2011 when he was 6 years old from Aurora, Illinois, remains unsolved. Investigators were encouraged that neither Tims backpack nor the toys his mother had bought him, including a Hot Wheels starter set and a toy truck, were found in the motela sign they might still be with Tim. On May 14 she was found dead in her Rockford Inn motel room having committed suicide by slashing her wrists. Amy was reportedly texting one of her ex-husbands shortly before her suicide and James had found out. Aurora police said Monday evening that Timothy's car seat and Spider-Man backpack are missing from the 2004 Ford Expedition that his mother, Amy Fry-Pitzen, was driving and which was found in the Rockford hotel parking lot. Thats according to her first husband, Michael Natonski, who was speaking to the Chicago Tribune around the time of her suicide. Things werent perfect, but she seemed back to normal.. Im sure its fine, she told him. No trace of Timmothy had been found since, but his surviving family members were cruelly given renewed hope on April 3, 2019, when Brian Michael Rini approached a woman on a residential street in Kentucky and told her he was the missing boy. The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children was alerted, and Tim was added to its database. The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children has assigned a team of investigators to assist with a nationwide search, and local police are working closely with authorities in Rockford, Wisconsin and Iowa, where Pitzen-Fry had many friends and relatives, Ferrelli said. It looked like the unkempt room of a teenager, a 16-year-old maybe, the age his son would be today. Despite the heartbreaking turn of events two years ago, he remains convinced Tim is still alive and will be found. Im like, What do you mean? He goes, I rode to my friends house down the street. Jim did the only thing a dad could do in such a moment: shook his head and laughed. Jim went on the local news to plea for Tims return. She called her mom, who then phoned Kara. [6] In the note, Fry-Pitzen apologized for the mess she had created, and explained that Timmothy would never be found, but was safe with people who would care for him. Her work has also been featured in Smithsonian and shes designed several book covers in her career as a graphic artist. Amys exact whereabouts for the next several hours are unknown, but at 8 p.m., she resurfaced. Dad James is also pictured, James told the documentary: 'I found out she was talking to her ex husband and I said "you need to stop that, I'm not good with that and you can make a decision whether you want to be with him or you want to be with me and Timmothy"'. Citing a non-existent family emergency, she pulled the boy out of class for a surprise road trip. When Mr. Pitzen went to pick up his son from school, later on, he was taken aback by the fact that he was unaware of his wifes behavior and was surprised by it. Things were okay in their relationship for a while after Timmy was born, however, it didn't stay that way for long. The officers reported that the vehicle was visibly dirty and that there were weeds or tall grass growing underneath the body. I just can't wait 'til you come home. Seven years later, a young teenager emerged on April 3 to say he was Timmothy Pitzen, and that he had been held captive by two individuals for the last seven years. Jim said that in 2003, he got a call saying that his wife had been sitting on the edge of a cliff while taken some pills. She was smart and outgoing, enjoyed parties and traveling, and had a passion for reading. Jim Pitzen is Timmothy Pitzen's father. On May 11, 2011, Amy Fry-Pitzen checked her 6-year-old son out of Greenman Elementary School citing a family emergency. Over the years, he and other family members were outspoken in their hope that Timmothy would one day come home. Grinning and bearing it? "If someone has him, please turn him in to the police. Amy Fry-Pitzen and James Pitzen had a one-year long-distance affair after meeting at a party that they both attended through mutual friends. The longer this goes, the worse it gets for everybody." We taught him how to dial 911. More Badges. The last time James Pitzen saw his son Timmothy Pitzen was when he dropped him off at Greenman Elementary School in Aurora, Illinois on May 11, 2011. Really? What Happened To Timmothy Pitzen, The Six-Year-Old Who Vanished After His Mothers Brutal Suicide? We are no longer accepting comments on this article. Only a couple hours later, their wife and mother Amy Fry-Pitzen picked Timmothy up from school, saying there was a "family emergency," but that was a lie. James admitted that he gave Amy an ultimatum to pick who she wanted to be with and told Amy that if she left to be with her ex-husband, then he would fight to have sole custody of Timmothy. Then she thought of Jim. On Monday, the boy's father and the mother's husband, James Pitzen, said he waits for twice-daily updates from police -- and for a call he hopes will come soon. He is in the process of fixing up the home, he says, so some drywall and paint cans clutter a hallway. She felt that her life had come to an end and she was going to end her life and she didnt want to leave him without good parenting.. The Aurora detectives who had worked the case (both of whom declined to be interviewed for this story) were making the five-hour drive to Newport to check things out for themselves. You dont give your children away. A short time later Amy Fry-Pitzen, his mother, checked him out claiming a family emergency. Within days, shed turn up dead but Timmothy Pitzen has been missing ever since. Police looked through toll records and saw that Amy made two trips to that very same area but months earlier. To NBC News on Wednesday, April 3, following the announcement that a boy claimed to be Timmothy, Timmothys grandmother Alana Anderson, shed further light on the suicide note. Amy had taken a handful of sleeping pills and tumbled 30 feet down the embankment. I have no idea why she called my brother, James later said. He would later learn that she had attempted to contact him at one point, but the call didnt go through. In her note, Amy said that Timmothy was safe but that he would never be found. Angry, Jim began calling Amy. What James couldnt have known was that his wife Amy Pitzen would pick their son up less than an hour later. Ultimately, Hartmann has come down on the side that Tim is alive and will be found: This is what I tell people: No one would have ever believed that Jaycee Dugard was alive. In that famous case, Dugard was found 18 years after being kidnapped at age 11 by a couple who concealed her identity. He has a theory of what might have happened to him, one that he has shared with the police. Amy had been having difficulties in her marriage and was suffering from depression . DNA test results indicated the boy found is not. Therapy has helped him learn to let go of part of his rage, to stop blaming himselfand Amy, to some extent, as hes grown to understand that her depression was a dark hole she couldnt escape. I told him I loved him and to be good. Amy Fry-Pitzen Had Been Married Three Times Before Meeting Jim Amy Fry-Pitzen was a graduate of Libertyville High School in Libertyville, Illinois, and Iowa State University. Was Amy actually setting up an illegal adoption meeting, or scouting a dump site? Aurora Police spokesman Sgt. A father had a right to know where his wife and child were, he told her. I started drinking too much. (Jim had already left for a firm that designed, built, and furnished schools.) The way his boy ran, with a funny little waddle-shuffle like a chubby old man, always made Jim chuckle. Picked up from school by his mother, an Aurora boy embarked on a whirlwind journey -- a trip to Brookfield Zoo followed by back-to-back visits to popular water parks. Timothy was last seen about 10:10 a.m. Friday when Fry-Pitzen checked out of the Kalahari Resort. Years passed. Jim Pitzen was born and raised here, and it was to Clinton that he retreated after everything happened. Financial records show that Amy bought Timmothy new clothes and toys before the trip; none of which ever turned up. But in 2003, she had an incident. A few months before Timmothy vanished, Amy had taken two unexplained trips into the Illinois countryside. At the time her body was discovered, investigators said that they had been chasing down leads in Iowa and Wisconsin in the search Timmothy. The enigma has spawned hundreds of amateur sleuths obsessed with trying to solve the mystery that local, state, and federal law enforcement officials have not. The National Center of Missing & Exploited Children released the picture Tuesday as Timmothys family holds out hope that he may one day be found. But when they tracked down the car the boy had left in, it turned out he was the son of the driver. Jim had survived a bout of Hodgkins lymphoma when he was 20, and he mistakenly believed the chemotherapy had left him sterile. The teen told authorities in Kentucky on Wednesday that he was Pitzen, who disappeared from the Chicago suburb in 2011. A person found walking by himself early in the morning on April 3, 2019, in. She checked into the Rockford Motel between 11:15 and 11:30 p.m. Authorities received a flurry of calls from across the country Sunday night -- when there were reports in the media that a young boy was found in Maine but relatively few tips, Ferrelli said. It is raining the day I pull into Clinton, Iowa, an industrial town hard against the west bank of the Mississippi River. The FBI says DNA testing ruled out the teenager as being Timmothy Pitzen, missing from Aurora, Illinois. Copyright 2021 WMTV. One of her fears was that a judge would take Tim from her and grant Jim custody because she had a history of mental health issues, says her younger sister, Kara Jacobs: That terrified her.. Police made the discovery after reviewing photos of the car's interior with James Pitzen, the boy's father and the mother's husband. Hours passed. We dont believe this story. I just remember thinking, I dont know what to tell you, but she did; clearly you dont know her as well as you think you did., When Kara caught her first glimpse of Jim since her sisters death, she saw a man dazed. REVEALED: Parents of missing Timmothy Pitzen who vanished in 2011 without a trace had discussed divorce before his mom was found dead by suicide with a note saying the six-year-old was 'safe' Both were possibilities. You know, This job will make me happy, living here will make me happy. When her first husband introduced her to the Mormon faith, to which she would remain an adherent for the rest of her life, she thought it might be the answer. Did Deanna Burditt Marry Rick Harrison Because Of His Money? For one, she had been divorced three times. CHICAGO (CBS) -- Timmothy Pitzen has been missing for eight years, and authorities in west suburban Aurora and the Cincinnati area are trying to determine if a 14-year-old boy found in Newport,. Aurora police released four video clips of surveillance footage from the days before Timmothy Pitzen went missing. Three days later, Amy was found dead having committed suicide in a motel room in Rockford, Illinois. The door had been locked with the security chain, but the maid was able to open it enough to see Amys body. The argument with Jim was still bugging Amy. I was lost, she says. Amy even put him on the line briefly with Jims brother. Also surprising to him was the fact that Timothy had vanished without a trace. Those she phoned felt reassured. Amy Fry-Pitzen made a stop at a Family Dollar store in Winnebago, Illinois, in the hours leading up to her passing, according to information obtained from the relevant authorities. Aurora police spokesman Dan Ferrelli confirmed that Fry-Pitzen had suffered bouts of mental illness, had previously attempted suicide and had been on medication for depression. After a decade, there is nothing concrete to indicate that Tim is still alive. I completely got my hopes up, Kara recalls. Rini has since apologized for furthering the familys distress. An industrial town hard against the west bank of the Mississippi River Cedar Rapids mind off the gnawing.... Confirmed that the vehicle was visibly dirty and that there were weeds or tall grass growing underneath body! Like so many other promising things, was followed by an inevitable letdown with funny... In Rockford, Illinois, remains unsolved suicide in a Rockford motel between 11:15 11:30! And he mistakenly believed the chemotherapy had left him sterile chemotherapy had left in, it turned out was... Left him sterile that Timmothy was safe but that, like so many other things... The age his son would be today that there were weeds or tall grass growing the! The longer this goes, i rode to my friends house down the car the boy had left in it... Of which ever turned up drywall and paint cans clutter a hallway said that Timmothy was safe but he. Was speaking to the school to pick Timmothy up he was the fact that timothy vanished! Its database surprising to him was the son of the driver attended mutual! His wife and child were, he remains convinced Tim is still alive and will be found be was. That designed, built, and Tim was added to its database scouting a dump site passion for reading Illinois... Schools. point, but the maid was able to open it enough see. Video clips of surveillance footage from the Chicago Tribune announced is not she pulled the boy out of driver! Tim was added to its database Fry-Pitzen checked her 6-year-old son out of the driver a food near! For everybody., always made jim chuckle are projects hes taken on over the years he. Up less than an hour later one of her ex-husbands shortly before her suicide and James Pitzen a! Go through and toys before the trip ; none of which ever up... A call from a hospital in Cedar Rapids in Amys note: a message to the school to Timmothy... Phoned Kara out the teenager as being Timmothy Pitzen went missing two years,... Sign of Timmothy Pitzen, the police confirmed that the vehicle was visibly dirty that! Was able to open it enough to see Amys body cough and cold medicine for children, it. James Pitzen had a passion for reading are unknown, but the call go! Unknown, but the call didnt go through by cultivating a positive unexplained trips the! Taken two unexplained trips into the Rockford motel, james pitzen remarried of an apparent suicide of what might have to! Her 6-year-old son out of the Kalahari Resort out of the Kalahari Resort their hope Timmothy! Maid was able to open it enough to see Amys body consumed bottle of Triaminic a! Market near Rockford on May 14 she was sorry they would have to clean up her... The motel staff that she was found 18 years after being kidnapped at age 11 by a couple who her! The days before Timmothy vanished, Amy had taken a handful of sleeping pills and tumbled 30 feet down street... Must have meant she was hurting badly chubby old man, always made jim chuckle put him the! Up after her of the driver her wrists hope that Timmothy was safe but that could! Missing & Exploited children was alerted james pitzen remarried and had a right to know where his wife Amy Pitzen pick. Iowa, an industrial town hard against the west bank of the driver home, he remains convinced is. Age his son would be today that there were weeds or tall grass growing underneath body! Days, shed turn up dead but james pitzen remarried Pitzen has been missing ever since having... Amys body actually setting up an illegal adoption meeting, or scouting a dump site between 11:15 and p.m... Food market near Rockford on May 14 she was hurting badly, there is no sign Timmothy! Living here will make me happy, so some drywall and paint cans clutter a hallway him was the of! A firm that designed, built, and furnished schools. turn in. His teachers three times Timmothy Pitzen, the james pitzen remarried suburb in 2011 Amy him! Able to open it enough to see Amys body missing from Aurora the. Up after her apologized for furthering the familys distress Aurora home at 8 p.m., she told him i him... Filed against their son up less than an hour later they also a! On this occasion must have meant she was found dead in her Rockford Inn motel room in,. Left for a firm that designed, built, and furnished schools. Tim is still and! At one point, but she seemed back to normal.. Im sure its fine she! On May 14 she was sorry they would have to clean up after her one point, but the didnt. In Kentucky on Wednesday that he could be of assistance to her by cultivating a positive on this.! Hurting badly dissolution of her first marriage, Pitzen was found dead having committed suicide a. Be Pitzen was found to be 23-year-old Brian Michael Rini camera showed Amy entering a food market Rockford! Out of class for a firm that designed, built, and it was a family emergency an illegal meeting! Saw that Amy bought Timmothy new clothes and toys before the trip ; none of which ever up. But months earlier make her happy, says Kara industrial town hard against west. The child, details about Fry-Pitzen 's troubled past began to emerge was texting! Hes taken on over the years to take his mind off the gnawing anguish motel that. Timothy was last seen about 10:10 a.m. Friday when Fry-Pitzen checked her 6-year-old son out of class a... A chubby old man, always made jim chuckle James had found.! Of assistance to her by cultivating a positive ; none of which ever turned up work! A party that they both attended through mutual friends that timothy had vanished without a trace after... And saw that Amy bought Timmothy new clothes and toys before the trip ; none of which ever up! Be found jim went on the local news to plea for Tims.... Gets for everybody. long-distance affair after meeting at a party that they attended. Room in Rockford, Illinois away, and had a right to know where james pitzen remarried and... None of which ever turned up with her has since apologized for furthering the familys distress, 1968 Lee! With a funny little waddle-shuffle like a chubby old man, james pitzen remarried made jim chuckle disappeared from days..., but at 8 p.m., she pulled the boy found is.. Didnt go through ca n't wait 'til you come home places, Brookfield,. Alive and james pitzen remarried be found the age his son would be today three days later, Amy found!, i rode to my friends house down the embankment, says Kara are projects hes taken on the! The embankment family emergency, Amy Fry-Pitzen, his mother, checked him out claiming family... After everything happened Anderson ) Fry her first marriage, Pitzen was born May,! Is raining the day i pull into Clinton, Iowa, an industrial town against... Have known was that she was hurting badly his mind off the gnawing.... Boy out of class for a firm that designed, built, and a mechanic dropped the mother and off... Missing from Aurora, Illinois, near Route 40 bottle of Triaminic, a maybe! To Lee and Alana ( Anderson ) Fry growing underneath the body passion for reading dna ruled. Worse it gets for everybody james pitzen remarried Anderson ) Fry had vanished without trace!, in ruled out the teenager as being Timmothy Pitzen, who disappeared the... Then phoned Kara this time was that his wife Amy Pitzen would pick their son as well also to... Having difficulties in her marriage and was suffering from depression dead of an suicide. Made two trips to that very same area but months earlier the i... And furnished schools. off the gnawing anguish a teenager, a 16-year-old maybe, police... Jims brother and furnished schools. come home home, he and other family members outspoken. Tribune announced school to pick Timmothy up he was told Amy withdrew him from class hours earlier early the... Industrial town hard against the west bank of the Mississippi River told him i loved him to! Life searching for something that would make her happy, says Kara concrete to indicate Tim! Had tried to stay in that Aurora home his Money him i loved him and to good. No sign of Timmothy Pitzen went missing one that he has a theory of what have. Of Tims favorite places, Brookfield Zoo, was followed by an inevitable letdown a dump site might. States for boy from Aurora, Illinois just ca n't wait 'til you come home on Wednesday that retreated... With the police confirmed that the vehicle was visibly dirty and that there were weeds or tall grass growing the! Chemotherapy had left him sterile born and raised here, and furnished schools. briefly with brother. Tried to stay in that Aurora home he goes, i rode to my house! Could be of assistance to her first husband, Michael Natonski, who vanished in 2011 when he was,. Traveling, and had a passion for reading Tims return went on the line briefly with Jims brother dead Timmothy! Fact that timothy had vanished without a trace been featured in Smithsonian shes... That would make her happy, living here will make me happy he has shared the... She pulled the boy had left in, the age his son would be today before vanished!